Skip to content
Longterm Wiki
All Source Checks
Citation

Samotsvety - Footnote 34

partial85% confidence

1 evidence check

Last checked: 4/3/2026

The claim mentions 'mutual assured destruction (MAD) principles and historical de-escalation patterns' as a reason for lower risk estimates. While the source mentions MAD principles and de-escalation, it doesn't explicitly link them as reasons for the group's lower risk estimates. The claim mentions 'critics argued this reflected overreliance on base rates and underestimation of tail risks.' The source mentions 'overreliance on certain base rates and underestimating Putin’s willingness to take major risks' but this is in the context of a forecaster reflecting on past errors, not necessarily a direct criticism of the October 2022 update.

Evidence — 1 source, 1 check

partial85%Haiku 4.5 · 4/3/2026
Found: The group's nuclear risk estimates tended to be lower than some external experts, partly due to different assumptions about evacuation possibilities and their aggregation methodology emphasizing mutua

Note: The claim mentions 'mutual assured destruction (MAD) principles and historical de-escalation patterns' as a reason for lower risk estimates. While the source mentions MAD principles and de-escalation, it doesn't explicitly link them as reasons for the group's lower risk estimates. The claim mentions 'critics argued this reflected overreliance on base rates and underestimation of tail risks.' The source mentions 'overreliance on certain base rates and underestimating Putin’s willingness to take major risks' but this is in the context of a forecaster reflecting on past errors, not necessarily a direct criticism of the October 2022 update.

Debug info

Record type: citation

Record ID: page:samotsvety:fn34

Source Check: Samotsvety - Footnote 34 | Longterm Wiki