Scorecard: fli_index 2025-12-02 scored xAI on Existential Safety = F
1 → contradicted
Our claim
entire record- Snapshot
- fli_index-winter-2025
- Entity
- xAI
- Dimension Slug
- existential-safety
- Dimension Label
- Existential Safety
- Score Numeric
- 0
- Score Letter
- F
- Score Raw
- F
Source evidence
1 src · 1 checkNoteThe record claims xAI received an 'F' grade for Existential Safety with a scoreNumeric of 0. The source confirms the letter grade 'F' for xAI in the Existential Safety domain (visible in the survey response grid under 'Domains Breakdown'). However, the record specifies scoreRaw: 'F' and scoreNumeric: 0, implying a numeric conversion. The source uses the US GPA system where F = 0.0, so scoreNumeric: 0 is consistent with the letter grade F. The contradiction arises because the source's overall xAI score is 1.17 (a D grade), not 0 — the record appears to conflate the domain-specific Existential Safety score (F = 0) with an overall score. The record's structure suggests it is reporting a domain-level grade, which is confirmed as 'F', but the scoreNumeric of 0 would only apply to that specific domain, not the company's overall index score. This is a partial contradiction: the letter grade is confirmed, but the numeric representation may be misleading if interpreted as the overall company score rather than the domain score.