Giving Pledge

{
  "id": "giving-pledge",
  "numericId": null,
  "path": "/knowledge-base/organizations/giving-pledge/",
  "filePath": "knowledge-base/organizations/giving-pledge.mdx",
  "title": "Giving Pledge",
  "quality": 68,
  "importance": 45,
  "contentFormat": "article",
  "tractability": null,
  "neglectedness": null,
  "uncertainty": null,
  "causalLevel": null,
  "lastUpdated": "2026-02-03",
  "llmSummary": "The Giving Pledge, while attracting 250+ billionaire signatories since 2010, has a disappointing track record with only 36% of deceased pledgers actually meeting their commitments and living pledgers growing wealth 166% faster than they give it away. The initiative functions more as reputation management than effective wealth redistribution, with 80% of funds going to donor-controlled foundations rather than operating charities.",
  "structuredSummary": null,
  "description": "A philanthropic initiative founded by Bill Gates, Melinda French Gates, and Warren Buffett in 2010 to encourage billionaires to donate the majority of their wealth to charitable causes",
  "ratings": {
    "novelty": 6,
    "rigor": 8,
    "actionability": 4,
    "completeness": 9
  },
  "category": "organizations",
  "subcategory": "funders",
  "clusters": [
    "ai-safety"
  ],
  "metrics": {
    "wordCount": 2631,
    "tableCount": 2,
    "diagramCount": 0,
    "internalLinks": 7,
    "externalLinks": 38,
    "footnoteCount": 36,
    "bulletRatio": 0.37,
    "sectionCount": 30,
    "hasOverview": true,
    "structuralScore": 11
  },
  "suggestedQuality": 73,
  "updateFrequency": 45,
  "evergreen": true,
  "wordCount": 2631,
  "unconvertedLinks": [],
  "unconvertedLinkCount": 0,
  "convertedLinkCount": 0,
  "backlinkCount": 4,
  "redundancy": {
    "maxSimilarity": 16,
    "similarPages": [
      {
        "id": "openai-foundation",
        "title": "OpenAI Foundation",
        "path": "/knowledge-base/organizations/openai-foundation/",
        "similarity": 16
      },
      {
        "id": "anthropic-investors",
        "title": "Anthropic (Funder)",
        "path": "/knowledge-base/organizations/anthropic-investors/",
        "similarity": 15
      },
      {
        "id": "chan-zuckerberg-initiative",
        "title": "Chan Zuckerberg Initiative",
        "path": "/knowledge-base/organizations/chan-zuckerberg-initiative/",
        "similarity": 15
      },
      {
        "id": "macarthur-foundation",
        "title": "MacArthur Foundation",
        "path": "/knowledge-base/organizations/macarthur-foundation/",
        "similarity": 15
      },
      {
        "id": "anthropic-pre-ipo-daf-transfers",
        "title": "Anthropic Pre-IPO DAF Transfers",
        "path": "/knowledge-base/organizations/anthropic-pre-ipo-daf-transfers/",
        "similarity": 14
      }
    ]
  }
}

{
  "id": "giving-pledge",
  "type": "organization",
  "title": "Giving Pledge",
  "description": "The Giving Pledge, while attracting 250+ billionaire signatories since 2010, has a disappointing track record with only 36% of deceased pledgers actually meeting their commitments and living pledgers growing wealth 166% faster than they give it away. The initiative functions more as reputation manag",
  "tags": [],
  "relatedEntries": [],
  "sources": [],
  "lastUpdated": "2026-02",
  "customFields": []
}

No facts for this entity

No external links

{
  "title": "Giving Pledge",
  "description": "A philanthropic initiative founded by Bill Gates, Melinda French Gates, and Warren Buffett in 2010 to encourage billionaires to donate the majority of their wealth to charitable causes",
  "importance": 45,
  "lastEdited": "2026-02-03",
  "update_frequency": 45,
  "sidebar": {
    "order": 50
  },
  "ratings": {
    "novelty": 6,
    "rigor": 8,
    "actionability": 4,
    "completeness": 9
  },
  "quality": 68,
  "llmSummary": "The Giving Pledge, while attracting 250+ billionaire signatories since 2010, has a disappointing track record with only 36% of deceased pledgers actually meeting their commitments and living pledgers growing wealth 166% faster than they give it away. The initiative functions more as reputation management than effective wealth redistribution, with 80% of funds going to donor-controlled foundations rather than operating charities.",
  "subcategory": "funders",
  "entityType": "organization"
}

---
title: Giving Pledge
description: A philanthropic initiative founded by Bill Gates, Melinda French Gates, and Warren Buffett in 2010 to encourage billionaires to donate the majority of their wealth to charitable causes
importance: 45
lastEdited: "2026-02-03"
update_frequency: 45
sidebar:
  order: 50
ratings:
  novelty: 6
  rigor: 8
  actionability: 4
  completeness: 9
quality: 68
llmSummary: The Giving Pledge, while attracting 250+ billionaire signatories since 2010, has a disappointing track record with only 36% of deceased pledgers actually meeting their commitments and living pledgers growing wealth 166% faster than they give it away. The initiative functions more as reputation management than effective wealth redistribution, with 80% of funds going to donor-controlled foundations rather than operating charities.
subcategory: funders
entityType: organization
---
import {EntityLink, KeyPeople, KeyQuestions, Section} from '@components/wiki';

## Quick Assessment

| Attribute | Assessment |
|-----------|------------|
| **Founded** | 2010 by Bill Gates, Melinda French Gates, and Warren Buffett |
| **Signatories** | Over 250 from 30 countries (as of October 2025) |
| **Commitment** | Donate majority (>50%) of wealth during lifetime or via will |
| **Binding Nature** | Voluntary, non-binding public pledge |
| **Fulfillment Rate** | Only 36% of deceased original pledgers met the 50% commitment[^1] |
| **Wealth Growth** | Original U.S. pledgers saw 166% inflation-adjusted wealth increase since 2010[^1] |
| **Fund Deployment** | ≈80% goes to private foundations/DAFs, ≈20% to working charities[^1] |

## Key Links

| Source | Link |
|--------|------|
| Official Website | [givingpledge.org](https://www.givingpledge.org) |
| Wikipedia | [en.wikipedia.org](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Giving_Pledge) |

## Overview

The **Giving Pledge** is a philanthropic initiative founded in 2010 by Bill Gates, Melinda French Gates, and Warren Buffett that commits the world's wealthiest individuals to donate the majority of their wealth to charitable causes during their lifetime or through their wills[^2][^3]. As of October 2025, the pledge has over 250 signatories from 30 countries, with a combined net worth of approximately \$600 billion[^4].

Rather than pooling or directing funds, the initiative creates a public commitment framework where signatories pursue their philanthropy independently while connecting with a global community of like-minded philanthropists[^5]. The pledge is not legally binding—it is a moral promise accompanied by a public letter explaining the signer's motivations[^6]. According to the organization, the goal is to "unlock vast resources to address the world's most urgent issues" and make philanthropy a central consideration for the wealthy[^3][^5].

However, a 2025 analysis by the Institute for Policy Studies revealed significant gaps between pledges and actual giving. Among the 22 original pledgers who have died, only 8 gave away enough to meet the "half of wealth" commitment by the time of their death[^1]. The 32 original U.S. pledgers who remain billionaires have collectively become approximately 166% wealthier (inflation-adjusted) since signing on in 2010, raising questions about whether the initiative is effectively redistributing wealth or simply providing reputational benefits while fortunes continue to grow[^1][^7].

## History

### Founding and Early Growth

The Giving Pledge was formally announced in June 2010, with Bill Gates, Melinda French Gates, and Warren Buffett beginning to recruit members[^8]. The initiative was inspired by philanthropist Chuck Feeney's "giving while living" ethic—Feeney gave away over \$8 billion during his lifetime, surrendering his billionaire status in the process[^9][^10].

The first 40 signatories were confirmed in August 2010, all from the United States, with an aggregate wealth of \$125 billion[^8][^11]. By April 2011, 69 billionaires had joined, and by 2012, the total reached 81[^12]. The pledge expanded internationally over time, growing to 158 signatories by May 2017 and 220 by March 2021[^12].

Notable milestones include:
- **2010**: Launch with 40 U.S. signatories representing about 14% of U.S. billionaires at the time[^13]
- **2014**: Launch of "Next Gen" group for children and grandchildren of pledgers to connect and support family philanthropy[^2][^3]
- **2022**: FTX founder Sam Bankman-Fried removed from the list following his arrest[^12]
- **2023**: Banker T. Denny Sanford removed after court documents revealed alleged child pornography involvement[^12]
- **2025**: Over 250 signatories from 30 countries; 15th anniversary celebrated[^2][^3]

### Recent Signatories (2025)

In 2025, 14 new billionaires joined the pledge, including founders of Moderna, Canva, and Craigslist[^14]. Notable new signatories include:

- **Cameron Adams and Lisa Miller** (Canva co-founders): Directing wealth toward biodiversity protection through the Wedgetail Foundation[^15]
- **Glen Tullman** (CEO of Transcarent): Focusing on education, health, and diabetes research[^15]
- **Stephanie Liu**: Committed to youth mental wellbeing and climate solutions through the Enlight Foundation[^15]
- **Lisa and Matt Sonsini**: Real estate wealth focused on income inequality and housing through the Sobrato Family Foundation[^14]

## Fulfillment Rates and Wealth Growth

### The 15-Year Track Record

A comprehensive 2025 report by the Institute for Policy Studies analyzing the original 2010 U.S. pledgers revealed troubling patterns[^1]:

**Fulfillment Among Deceased Pledgers:**
- Of the 22 original pledgers who have died, only 8 (36%) actually gave away enough to meet the "half of wealth" commitment by the time of their death[^1]
- Examples of non-fulfillment include Paul Allen, who pledged in 2010 with a \$13.5 billion net worth, donated \$2 billion during his lifetime, but died in 2019 with over \$20 billion in assets[^16]

**Wealth Growth Among Living Pledgers:**
- The 32 original U.S. pledgers who remain billionaires have collectively become approximately 166% wealthier (inflation-adjusted) since signing in 2010[^1][^7]
- In absolute terms, these pledgers saw a 283% increase in wealth (non-inflation-adjusted)[^1]
- Approximately 75% of living original U.S. pledgers remain billionaires and are wealthier than when they signed[^17]

**Age and Fulfillment Correlation:**
- Older pledgers at the time of signing were more likely to fulfill their commitments[^1]
- Younger signatories have seen their wealth grow faster than their giving, as their businesses and investments have appreciated[^1]

### Where the Money Goes

According to the Institute for Policy Studies analysis, roughly 80% of pledger contributions have gone to intermediary organizations—primarily private family foundations and donor-advised funds (DAFs)—rather than directly to operating charities[^1][^4]:

- \$164 billion to private foundations
- \$5+ billion to DAFs (likely an undercount)
- Living pledgers' foundations held \$120 billion in assets as of 2023[^17]
- Median foundation payout rate: 9.2% (2023)[^17]

Supporters argue this approach builds enduring endowments and professionalizes grantmaking, allowing for strategic long-term impact. Critics contend it delays actual charitable impact, preserves donor control, and provides immediate tax benefits while allowing disbursements over time—blurring the line between philanthropy and the maintenance of wealth and influence[^1][^4].

## Structure and Operation

### How the Pledge Works

The Giving Pledge operates through several key mechanisms:

1. **Public Commitment**: Philanthropists join by making a public commitment, typically writing a letter explaining their reasons for giving[^3]
2. **Individual Autonomy**: Members give at their own pace in multiple ways, with no requirement to support specific causes[^5]
3. **Community Learning**: The initiative holds learning sessions throughout the year, including an annual two-day conference where members discuss experiences and learn from experts[^18]
4. **Next Generation Engagement**: Established in 2014, the Next Gen group engages children and grandchildren of pledgers in philanthropic efforts[^3]

The pledge does not pool or grant funds—it is not a grant-making entity[^5]. Each signatory pursues their philanthropic goals independently, typically through personal foundations, nonprofits, or direct donations. Pledge letters are publicly available on GivingPledge.org[^5].

### Target Demographics

The pledge primarily targets individuals with net worths of at least \$1 billion (or equivalent after prior giving)[^19]. As of 2025, most signatories are billionaires, though not all pledgers meet this threshold[^12]. The demographic profile of signatories has been described as predominantly male, white, and U.S.-based, though international participation has grown over time[^20].

## Relevance to AI Safety and Tech Philanthropy

### Tech Billionaire Participation

Many technology industry leaders have signed the Giving Pledge, including:

- **<EntityLink id="E116">Elon Musk</EntityLink>** (2012): Net worth ≈\$400B; ≈\$250M/year through Musk Foundation (see <EntityLink id="E410">Elon Musk Philanthropy</EntityLink>)
- **Mark Zuckerberg** (2010): Net worth ≈\$200B; ≈\$8B donated through CZI (pledged 99% of shares, initially valued at \$45B)
- **Larry Ellison** (2010): Net worth ≈\$230B; estimated \$0.8B donated[^12]
- **<EntityLink id="E436">Dustin Moskovitz</EntityLink>** (2010): Net worth ≈\$17B; \$4B+ donated through <EntityLink id="E521">Coefficient Giving</EntityLink>

### Anthropic Founders and AI Safety Funding

The Giving Pledge's relevance to AI safety extends through several mechanisms:

1. **Affiliated Giving Organizations**: Organizations like Founders Pledge and Giving What We Can have emphasized AI safety as a priority cause area, with Founders Pledge funding projects building "global resilience to AI risks"[^21]

2. **Effective Altruism Connections**: The pledge has influenced EA-focused giving initiatives, which have in turn supported AI safety research through organizations like <EntityLink id="E202">MIRI</EntityLink>, <EntityLink id="E557">Redwood Research</EntityLink>, and <EntityLink id="E22">Anthropic</EntityLink>[^22]

3. **Long-Term Thinking**: The pledge's emphasis on addressing "the world's most urgent issues" aligns with existential risk reduction, though explicit commitments to AI safety specifically are limited in public pledge letters[^21][^22]

However, there is no direct statement from the Giving Pledge organization explicitly linking to AI safety, alignment, or existential risk topics. The connection is primarily indirect through related organizations and the broader effective altruism ecosystem[^21][^22].

## Criticisms and Controversies

### Lack of Accountability and Enforcement

The Giving Pledge has attracted substantial criticism for its voluntary, non-binding nature:

- **No Verification Mechanism**: There is no system to verify or enforce the fulfillment of commitments[^4][^7]
- **Public Recognition Without Action**: Commentators note that some signatories may gain positive public recognition without necessarily donating the pledged share[^7]
- **Non-Binding Promise**: As a moral promise rather than a legal contract (lacking elements like consideration), the pledge relies solely on public commitment rather than enforceable agreements[^6][^23]

### Foundation Parking and Slow Deployment

Critics argue that directing the majority of donations to private foundations and DAFs undermines the pledge's stated goal of addressing urgent issues:

- **Delayed Impact**: Foundations allow for strategic giving over decades, but this means resources sit in endowments rather than being deployed to current needs[^1][^4]
- **Donor Control**: Private foundations preserve donor influence over grantmaking, raising questions about whether this constitutes true philanthropy or merely a transfer of assets between entities the donor controls[^1][^4]
- **Median Payout Rates**: At a median 9.2% payout rate, foundation-held wealth grows faster than it's distributed[^17]

### Tax Benefits and Wealth Preservation

The pledge has been criticized as a mechanism for tax optimization and wealth preservation:

- **Immediate Tax Deductions**: Donors receive tax benefits upon transferring assets to foundations or DAFs, even though the money may not reach working charities for years or decades[^1]
- **Wealth Growth Outpacing Giving**: For the original pledgers still alive, wealth has grown 166% (inflation-adjusted) since 2010, suggesting that fortunes are compounding faster than they're being given away[^1][^7]
- **Examples of Tax Optimization**: Cases like Elon Musk's stock transfers and "donation ping-ponging" for tax benefits without substantial outflow have been documented[^24]

### Effectiveness and Impact Questions

Several analyses have questioned whether the pledge is "living up to its promise":

- Warren Buffett himself admitted in November 2025 that his Giving Pledge philanthropy approach was not "feasible," indicating a rethinking of his fortune's allocation[^25]
- Melinda French Gates, who left the Gates Foundation in 2024, has been critical of the billionaire class's giving patterns[^26]
- Despite the pledge, U.S. charitable giving has remained stagnant at approximately 2% of GDP for decades, failing to "turbocharge" donations as hoped[^27]
- Fewer than 1 in 6 billionaires have signed the pledge, suggesting limited broad participation[^27]

### Criticism of Philanthropic Focus

Some critics argue that the pledge's approach to philanthropy is misguided:

- **Tech-Heavy Focus**: The Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation has been criticized for a tech-centric approach that neglects social determinants of health, with controversies including vaccine inequity during COVID-19[^28][^29]
- **Perpetuating Inequality**: The Institute for Policy Studies characterizes the pledge as enabling reputation-building without addressing the underlying inequality and tax rules that fuel wealth concentration[^30]
- **Elite Networks Over Equity**: The exclusive focus on billionaires may amplify uneven philanthropic priorities rather than democratizing charitable giving[^20]

## Founder Perspectives and Distancing

### Warren Buffett's Retreat

Warren Buffett, co-founder of the Giving Pledge, has shown signs of distancing himself from the initiative:

- In November 2025, Buffett admitted that his early "grand philanthropic plans" proved "not feasible"[^31][^27]
- He noted he dislikes "preaching" about philanthropy[^27]
- Buffett has stepped back from foundation governance amid uncertainty about its future[^26]

### Melinda French Gates' Criticism

Melinda French Gates, who left the Gates Foundation in 2024, wrote in a 2025 letter that "ripped" the billionaire class and characterized the Giving Pledge as inadequate[^30][^31]. Her critique represents a significant departure from the initiative's founding optimism.

### Bill Gates' Continued Support

Bill Gates has remained the most vocal supporter of the pledge. In 2025, he announced a new class of pledgers and emphasized: "There's never been a greater need for philanthropy — and there has never been a greater opportunity to have an impact in our own lifetimes."[^32][^26]

In May 2025, Gates pledged to eventually direct "virtually all" of his approximately \$100 billion wealth to the Gates Foundation, which he announced would shut down to accelerate giving[^26].

## Comparison to Other Giving Initiatives

### Giving What We Can

In effective altruism communities, the Giving Pledge is viewed as distinct from and less relevant than initiatives like Giving What We Can's (GWWC) 10% Pledge:

- **GWWC 10% Pledge**: Lifetime commitment to donate 10% of income, targeting average earners rather than billionaires[^33][^34]
- **Trial Pledges**: GWWC offers flexible 1-10% pledges for 6 months to 5 years[^34]
- **Community Norms**: The 10% pledge is seen as an EA community standard, with discussions around income-scaled or dynamic pledges to address fairness concerns[^33][^35]

### Founders Pledge and Coefficient Giving

Other organizations have built on the Giving Pledge model with more specific cause focus:

- **Founders Pledge**: Targets startup founders and has explicitly funded AI safety and governance work[^21]
- **Coefficient Giving**: Operates an AI Governance Fund for proposals aimed at reducing global catastrophic risks[^36]
- **Jewish Future Pledge**: Launched in 2020, inspired by the Giving Pledge, encouraging American Jews to give at least half of their charitable giving to Jewish or Israel-related causes[^12]

## Key Uncertainties

1. **Future Fulfillment Rates**: Will the fulfillment rate improve as more original pledgers reach the end of their lives, or will the 36% rate among deceased pledgers hold steady?

2. **Foundation Deployment**: How quickly will the \$120 billion held in living pledgers' foundations be deployed to working charities, and will payout rates increase beyond the current 9.2% median?

3. **Wealth Growth vs. Giving**: For living pledgers whose wealth continues to compound, at what point will giving outpace wealth accumulation?

4. **International Expansion**: Will the pledge successfully expand beyond its predominantly U.S., white, male demographic to include more diverse international participants?

5. **AI Safety Relevance**: As AI safety becomes a more prominent cause area, will more tech billionaire pledgers explicitly commit resources to AI existential risk reduction?

6. **Structural Reforms**: Will criticisms lead to structural changes such as verification mechanisms, required timelines, or minimum payout rates for foundation-based giving?

7. **Successor Initiative**: Given co-founder Buffett's admission that the approach was "not feasible" and French Gates' criticisms, will a reformed or successor initiative emerge?

## Sources

[^1]: [Institute for Policy Studies - The Giving Pledge at 15](https://ips-dc.org/report-giving-pledge-at-15/)
[^2]: [Giving Pledge - About](https://www.givingpledge.org/about-the-giving-pledge/)
[^3]: [Giving Pledge - About the Giving Pledge](https://www.givingpledge.org/about-the-giving-pledge/)
[^4]: [Wikipedia - The Giving Pledge](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Giving_Pledge)
[^5]: [Giving Pledge - Fact Sheet August 2025](https://www.givingpledge.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/08/The-Giving-Pledge-Fact-Sheet-August-2025.pdf)
[^6]: [Britannica - The Giving Pledge](https://www.britannica.com/money/the-Giving-Pledge)
[^7]: [Nonprofit Quarterly - The Giving Pledge at 15](https://nonprofitquarterly.org/the-giving-pledge-at-15-philanthropic-catalyst-empty-promise-or-both/)
[^8]: [Giving Pledge - FAQ](https://www.givingpledge.org/frequently-asked-questions/)
[^9]: [Atlantic Philanthropies - History of the Giving While Living Ethic](https://www.atlanticphilanthropies.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/05/History_of_the_Giving_While_Living_Ethic.pdf)
[^10]: [IPS Report - Giving Pledge at 15](https://ips-dc.org/report-giving-pledge-at-15/)
[^11]: [Britannica - Giving Pledge History](https://www.britannica.com/money/the-Giving-Pledge)
[^12]: [Wikipedia - Giving Pledge History](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Giving_Pledge)
[^13]: [IPS - Giving Pledge at 15 Analysis](https://ips-dc.org/report-giving-pledge-at-15/)
[^14]: [Observer - Billionaire Families Join Giving Pledge 2025](https://observer.com/2025/12/billionaire-families-join-giving-pledge-2025/)
[^15]: [Inside Philanthropy - Who Signed the Giving Pledge in 2025](https://www.insidephilanthropy.com/home/heres-who-signed-the-giving-pledge-in-2025)
[^16]: [The Prospect - Billionaire Class Created Failed Wealth Tax](https://prospect.org/2019/11/08/billionaire-class-created-failed-wealth-tax-giving-pledge/)
[^17]: [Capital Research - Report on the Giving Pledge](https://capitalresearch.org/article/a-report-on-the-giving-pledge-wealth-is-growing-faster-than-its-given-away/)
[^18]: [Cummings Foundation - Giving Pledge](https://www.cummingsfoundation.org/about/giving-pledge.html)
[^19]: [Giving Pledge Fact Sheet](https://www.givingpledge.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/08/The-Giving-Pledge-Fact-Sheet-August-2025.pdf)
[^20]: [PMC - Billionaires in Global Philanthropy](https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8147574/)
[^21]: [Founders Pledge - Building Global Resilience to AI Risks](https://www.founderspledge.com/research/building-global-resilience-to-ai-risks)
[^22]: [Giving What We Can - Artificial Intelligence](https://www.givingwhatwecan.org/cause-areas/reducing-global-catastrophic-risks/artificial-intelligence)
[^23]: [Perlman & Perlman - Charitable Pledge](https://perlmanandperlman.com/charitable-pledge/)
[^24]: [Katie Couric - Billionaire Philanthropy Giving Pledge Failure](https://katiecouric.com/news/social-impact/billionaire-philanthropy-giving-pledge-failure/)
[^25]: [Fortune - Warren Buffett Admits Giving Pledge Not Feasible](https://fortune.com/videos/watch/warren-buffett-admits-his-giving-pledge-philanthropy-was-not-%E2%80%9Cfeasible%E2%80%9D/369fb27f-1731-4f84-b68c-c686390cb129)
[^26]: [Fortune - Melinda French Gates Rips Billionaire Class](https://fortune.com/2025/12/04/melinda-french-gates-rips-billionaire-class-giving-pledge/)
[^27]: [Bill High - What Happened to the Giving Pledge](https://billhigh.com/generosity/what-happened-to-the-giving-pledge/)
[^28]: [YouTube - Tim Schwab Talk on Gates Foundation](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1e4SdZqceGg)
[^29]: [247 Wall St - Failures of Philanthropy](https://247wallst.com/investing/2020/12/02/a-closer-look-failures-of-philanthropy/)
[^30]: [Alliance Magazine - Giving Pledge Billionaires Impoverish Public Life](https://www.alliancemagazine.org/blog/giving-pledge-billionaires-impoverish-public-life-and-leave-philanthropy-promise-unfulfilled-study-reveals/)
[^31]: [Fortune - Melinda French Gates December 2025](https://fortune.com/2025/12/04/melinda-french-gates-rips-billionaire-class-giving-pledge/)
[^32]: [IPS - Giving Pledge at 15 Report](https://ips-dc.org/report-giving-pledge-at-15/)
[^33]: [EA Forum - Why I Donate and Dynamic Pledge](https://forum.effectivealtruism.org/posts/74gbLxsFAiG33T8EL/why-i-donate-and-why-i-m-committing-to-a-dynamic-pledge)
[^34]: [EA Forum - Giving What We Can Users](https://forum.effectivealtruism.org/users/giving-what-we-can)
[^35]: [EA Forum - Rethinking the 10% Giving Pledge](https://forum.effectivealtruism.org/posts/8vdthvfNXc7J9MB6Q/rethinking-the-10-giving-pledge-questions-from-a-recent-grad)
[^36]: [Coefficient Giving - AI Governance RFP](https://coefficientgiving.org/funds/navigating-transformative-ai/request-for-proposals-ai-governance/)